Comic Book Superman Year One
Storm Score 64 out of 100
Reviews 2 published
Outlets 1 publications
Top Outlet IGN highest score
% Positive 50% acclaim+

Critics' Consensus

“Critics praise superman year one's fresh take on Clark Kent but fault its rehashed tropes and uneven execution.”

Not Yet
Rated 64 / 100
Tier Distribution 2 reviews total
0%
50%
50%
Universal Acclaim (90–100): 0 reviews
Critically Acclaimed (70–89): 1 reviews
Mixed Reception (<70): 1 reviews

Critical Assessment

What Critics Praise

  • Solid Artwork
  • Compelling Premise
  • Rich Character Development
  • Intriguing Plot Twists
  • Balanced Moral Compass Exploration

Points of Contention

  • Repetitive Tropes
  • Uneven Pacing

Professional Reviews

2 reviews from 1 critic
71
Jesse Schedeen 2 reviews · avg
IGN

“Superman: Year One #2 is a flawed take on the idea of Clark Kent: Military Man, but at least it's a unique one.”

Acclaimed 57–71 across 2

All 2 Jesse Schedeen reviews, aggregated above

71
Superman: Year One #2

“Superman: Year One #2 is a flawed take on the idea of Clark Kent: Military Man, but at least it's a unique one.”

Critically Acclaimed 7.1/10
57
DC Gives Superman's Origin a Troubling Overhaul (Superman: Year One #1

“Superman: Year One alternates between rehashing familiar tropes and adding unnecessary new elements to the mythos.”

Mixed Reception 5.7/10

Similar Products

More in Comic Book

View all →