“The Flash offered its best episode of Season 5 yet with a fun body swap featuring Barry Allen and Oliver Queen.”
Critical Assessment
What Critics Praise
- Strong character development
- Balanced tone
- Compelling family drama
- Visual flair
- Grant Gustin’s Performance
- Standalone Story
Points of Contention
- Uneven pacing
- Underdeveloped villain
- Filler feel
- Season‑Long Context
- Tacked‑on subplot
Professional Reviews
56 reviews from 6 critics85 Craig Byrne 2 reviews · avg IGN “The Flash wraps up the first half of Season 6 with good scares and a compelling prelude to Crisis on Infinite Earths.”
“The Flash wraps up the first half of Season 6 with good scares and a compelling prelude to Crisis on Infinite Earths.”
All 2 Craig Byrne reviews, aggregated above
“The Flash wraps up the first half of Season 6 with good scares and a compelling prelude to Crisis on Infinite Earths.”
“The Flash falls into familiar tropes by spending a bit too much time inside Barry's head with only two weeks to its upcoming Crisis.”
72 Jesse Schedeen 48 reviews · avg IGN “The Flash wrapped up a major phase of Season 5, but the strong buildup led to an underwhelming payoff.”
“The Flash wrapped up a major phase of Season 5, but the strong buildup led to an underwhelming payoff.”
All 48 Jesse Schedeen reviews, aggregated above
“The Flash finally experienced a return to form this week thanks to a more streamlined and focused episode.”
“There Will Be Blood is a great reminder of how much character drama and family dynamics are the beating heart of the series, not superhero spectacle.”
“Still, a win is a win, and “Goldfaced” is a welcome example of the series firing on all cylinders with its ensemble cast.”
“The Flash's sixth season continues to address the series' chronic flaws, even as it introduces a wacky new hero.”
“"Legacy" is a memorable and emotionally rich ending to an otherwise disappointing season of The Flash.”
“The Flash finally found its groove again this week as metahuman fun collided with grounded character drama.”
“The Flash's new season is shaping up nicely, with this week's episode proving both eventful and entertaining.”
“The Flash delivers memorable payoff to a long-running mystery, as Elongated Man finally meets his woman.”
“This episode, as much as any other this season, demonstrates how much better The Flash has gotten about tonal balance and organically shifting between humor and darkness.”
“The Flash starts out the new year strong as Crisis paves the way for new threats in Central City.”
“As flawed as Season 5 was, this feels like a fitting and necessary coda.”
“The Flash: Season 6 ends several episodes early, but the result is much more satisfying than expected.”
“This is the first installment of Crisis that really seems to bite off more than it can chew in terms of story.”
“"Liberation" is just what the Flash needed, pushing the ongoing Mirror Master arc forward in a big way.”
“Despite an underwhelming new villain, this week's Flash delivered a solid balance of humor and family drama.”
“The Flash finally ends its long, downward slump in Season 6, as Crisis on Infinite Earths reinvigorates the series.”
“This week's Flash delivers a mostly satisfying Thanksgiving meal full of family drama and holiday cheer.”
“"Godspeed" falters when it comes to the title character, but it makes the most of its Nora/Thawne-heavy storyline.”
“So far, that approach is paying off, even if Episode 2 bombards viewers with a bit too much material.”
“Despite a bland metahuman storyline, this week's Flash offered a promising taste of things to come for Barry Allen.”
“The Flash moved into darker territory this week, and the series benefited as a result.”
“While this episode can’t entirely escape the sluggishness that’s been weighing down the series for months, it does offer some great giant monster payoff.”
“The good news is that Nora's debut is one element that does seem to be working in the show's favor at this early stage.”
“The Flash begins Season 6 with a promising debut episode that addresses some of the show’s bigger flaws.”
“The idea that DeVoe needed 12 hours to charge his doomsday satellites felt like an unnecessary stalling tactic and plot contrivance.”
“This week's episode of The Flash worked mostly when the DeVoe family took the spotlight.”
“The Flash followed a predictable but enjoyable path this week as iris briefly became a speedster.”
“The Flash wrapped up a major phase of Season 5, but the strong buildup led to an underwhelming payoff.”
“Citizen Cold provided a major boost to what might otherwise have been a mediocre new Flash episode.”
“The Flash makes strong use of its ensemble cast of villains, but the momentum isn't there as the season finale nears.”
“The Flash gets silly for Valentine's Day, but the series also continues building up the threat of Mirror Master.”
“The Flash's latest Gorilla Grodd episode is small in scope but delivers a satisfying transformation for this villain.”
“The Flash brings back two recurring villains in "Pay the Piper," but only one of them lives up to their potential.”
The episode delivers strong character moments and a nuanced portrayal of Clifford DeVoe, but fails to develop its villains beyond one-dimensional archetypes. The writers struggle to balance comedy and drama, resulting in missed opportunities for deeper narrative tension.
“The Flash's midseason premiere is a bit bland, but bigger things loom on the horizon for the series.”
“The Flash's 100th episode sets the stage for a compelling new conflict but often squanders its own premise.”
“Cicada comes across as little more than a stalling mechanism until the show is ready to dive headlong into the far more compelling Nora/Eobard Thawne alliance.”
“This week's episode of The Flash took a pointless detour at a less than opportune time.”
“The Flash continues to struggle to balance out its goofy sense of humor with real, compelling drama.”
“The Flash struggles to make use of its supporting cast, including an underwhleming new version of Harrison Wells.”
“The Flash brings Ragdoll back for another creepy romp, but the series still struggles to do justice to this villain.”
“This is easily one of the most uneven and frustrating installments of the show in a very long time.”
“Season 5 may not quite rank as the show’s worst to date, but at some point that’s an almost meaningless distinction.”
“The Flash disappointed this week as it failed to channel the quirky appeal of Rag Doll.”
“The Flash lacked balance and focus in its fourth season, resulting in the series' most disappointing year so far.”
“The Flash tries and fails to pay tribute to Groundhog Day in "Cause and XS."”
“The Flash continues to languish as the Season 5 finale looms, but one major twist offers some hope.”
“The Flash ends its weakest season with its weakest season finale.”
“Barry and Iris' trip to Nora's memory gives a meaningful glimpse of the future but frustratingly delays Cicada's story.”
68 Laura Prudom 3 reviews · avg IGN “The Flash seems to be stuck in a time loop in the battle against DeVoe, and it's running out of time to make us care.”
“The Flash seems to be stuck in a time loop in the battle against DeVoe, and it's running out of time to make us care.”
All 3 Laura Prudom reviews, aggregated above
The episode delivers a fresh and well-executed James Bond homage with strong character development for Barry and Ralph. Minor pacing issues in subplots do not detract from its overall quality as a worthwhile installment.
“The Flash seems to be stuck in a time loop in the battle against DeVoe, and it's running out of time to make us care.”
“Caitlin gets some necessary backstory in "The Icicle Cometh," but clunky writing and predictable twists leave us cold.”
“The Flash Season 4 resumed business as usual in this week's very underwhelming new episode.”
